Best Bait for Crappie Fishing [For a Successful Catch]


When it comes to fishing for crappie, having the right bait can make all the difference. Crappie are known for being finicky eaters, so finding the right bait can be a challenge. There are many different types of bait available on the market, but not all of them are created equal. In this article, we will be discussing the best bait for crappie fishing.

Berkley PowerBait Crappie Nibbles Dough Fishing Bait Glow/Chartreuse 1-Pack Powerbait

 

Berkley PowerBait Crappie Nibbles Dough Fishing Bait Glow/Chartreuse 1-Pack Powerbait is a great tool for anglers who want to catch more fish.

Pros

  • Berkley PowerBait Chroma-Glow Crappie Nibbles Dough Bait featuring Berkley’s irresistible PowerBait flavor and a glowing formula.
  • Extreme scent dispersion, slowly dissolving in the water – dispersing a scent cloud that crappie and other panfish species can’t resist.
  • Exclusive PowerBait formula that fish love so much they hold on 18 times longer, giving you the time and confidence to Feel More Bites.

Cons

  • Comes off the hook easily.
  • Smaller than expected.
  • Some users have reported that they have not been successful in catching fish.

We recently tried Berkley PowerBait Crappie Nibbles Dough Fishing Bait Glow/Chartreuse 1-Pack Powerbait and were impressed with its performance. The Chroma-Glow formula and irresistible scent make it an excellent choice for catching crappie and other panfish species.

We found the dough-like consistency of the bait easy to work with and appreciated the variety of colors available to choose from based on our fishing preferences and environment. We also liked that it could be mashed over the hook, run on a tipping jig, or used to fill tube baits.

However, we did notice that the bait comes off the hook easily, and it was smaller than we expected. Some users have also reported that they have not been successful in catching fish.

I have caught many using pb. I put a small ball on my hook and throw it out, then I move it a little. I reel in and check after 15min, then put on some fresh pb and try again. I have caught trout, sunnies, and catfish using this method.

Magic Bait Crappie Bites Crappie Nibbles Fishing Lures

 

If you’re looking for a natural crappie attractant that is easy to use and effective, then the Magic Bait Crappie Bites are worth considering.

Pros

  • Catch more Slabs with this bait
  • Mess-free and does not require refrigeration
  • Conveniently comes in a plastic jar

Cons

  • Some users reported that it did not work for them
  • The jar may be smaller than expected
  • Higher price compared to other bait options

We recently tested the Magic Bait Crappie Bites and found that they are a reliable option for catching crappie. The chartreuse/pink color and scent of these crappie nibbles are highly attractive to freshwater prey, making them a great addition to your fishing gear.

One of the biggest advantages of this bait is that it is mess-free and does not require refrigeration. This makes it easy to bring along with other fishing accessories and use on the go. The bait also comes in a handy plastic jar that is easy to open and close.

However, some users reported that the bait did not work for them, and they did not catch any fish. Additionally, the jar may be smaller than expected, and the price is higher compared to other bait options.

I tried homemade bait

I never thought that hotdogs and marshmallows could be used as bait for fishing until I tried it myself. I was out on the lake with my friends, hoping to catch some crappie for dinner. We had brought along our usual bait, but after a few hours with no luck, we decided to get creative.

I remembered hearing about using unconventional bait for fishing, so we rummaged through our cooler and found some leftover hotdogs and marshmallows from our cookout the night before. We cut the hotdogs into small pieces and threaded them onto our hooks, then added a few marshmallows for extra attraction. To our surprise, the crappie couldn’t resist it. We caught more fish in the next hour than we had all day. It was a fun and unexpected success, and I couldn’t wait to share our experience with others.

 

Dovesun 120pcs Crappie Lures Kit

 

If you’re looking for a comprehensive crappie lures kit, the Dovesun 120pcs Crappie Lures Kit is a great choice.

Pros

  • The kit includes 9 colors of soft plastic tube baits that are incredibly durable and resist tearing, even when used with jigheads.
  • The tube baits have free-moving tails that create a natural undulation, making them irresistible to crappie.
  • The kit comes with a portable box to keep everything organized and easy to transport.

Cons

  • Some users have reported that the hooks are smaller than anticipated.
  • The eyes on the lures may be lighter than expected.
  • The kit may not include enough of certain colors for some users.

We recently had the opportunity to try out the Dovesun 120pcs Crappie Lures Kit, and we were impressed with the versatility and quality of the lures. The soft plastic tube baits are available in nine colors that are sure to match any hatch, and they’re incredibly durable. We fished with them using jigheads, and they held up well even after multiple strikes.

One of the standout features of this kit is the realistic details on the tube baits. The body of the bait is poured with soft plastic, giving it a natural feel, while the nose integrates a dense section to increase durability and make rigging easier. The baits are also impregnated with salt, which provides an ideal sinking rate and makes them move realistically through the water.

We found that the lures in this kit are incredibly versatile and can be used in almost any situation. They’re perfect for targeting crappie, but they can also be used to catch other species like smallmouth bass and ocean sunfish. The kit includes a range of hatch-matching colors, including convincingly lifelike HD colors, which is sure to help deliver plenty of tournament checks.

Overall, we would definitely recommend the Dovesun 120pcs Crappie Lures Kit to anyone looking for a comprehensive and high-quality crappie lure kit. With its flexible tube baits, realistic details, and versatile colors, this kit is sure to help you catch more fish.

Magic Bait CRP-02 Crappie Bites, White

 

If you are looking for a reliable bait for crappie fishing, we highly recommend Magic Bait CRP-02 Crappie Bites. This bait is perfect for catching more slabs and is manufactured in the United States.

Pros

  • The white/chartreuse color of the bait is highly attractive to crappie and helps you catch more fish.
  • The bait is easy to use and can be used with jigs or on a hook.
  • The package dimensions are 8.8″L x 6.8″W x 4.1″H, making it easy to store and transport.

Cons

  • Some users have reported that the bait is not as effective in murky water.
  • The bait may dry out quickly if not stored properly.
  • The bait may not be as effective in colder water temperatures.

In our experience, Magic Bait CRP-02 Crappie Bites is a great choice for crappie fishing. The white/chartreuse color of the bait is highly attractive to crappie and helps you catch more fish. We found the bait to be easy to use and it can be used with jigs or on a hook. Additionally, the package dimensions are 8.8″L x 6.8″W x 4.1″H, making it easy to store and transport.

However, some users have reported that the bait is not as effective in murky water. Additionally, the bait may dry out quickly if not stored properly and may not be as effective in colder water temperatures. Overall, we believe that Magic Bait CRP-02 Crappie Bites is a reliable and effective bait for crappie fishing.

XFISHMAN Tube Baits Kit

 

If you’re looking for a versatile and complete bait kit for crappie fishing, the XFISHMAN Tube Baits Kit is a must-have. Here’s why:

Pros

  • The kit includes 120 tube baits in 10 effective colors, so you can adapt to any water condition and fish behavior.
  • The tube baits are 2 inches long and 1/4 inch in diameter, with a soft body and multiple tentacle tails that give the bait its action. The tube mimics something that is alive, making it a great choice for crappie fishing.
  • The kit also includes 10 tube jig heads in 2 sizes (1/16 oz and 1/32 oz), so you can experiment with different weights and depths.

Cons

  • Some users have reported that some of the tubes have errors, with the skirt thing often having a few thick strands, and some of the individual things tail things being combined.
  • The kit may not be suitable for larger fish species, as the tube baits are relatively small.

Overall, the XFISHMAN Tube Baits Kit is a great choice for any crappie angler who wants to have everything they need to go fishing in any condition. The kit is easy to use and comes in a thin lure box for easy access. With 10 classic colors in the kit to suit every water situation, you can be sure to find the right one for your next catch. The tube jig heads are also a great addition, as they allow the tube baits to dance along the lake floor with a tempting action. We highly recommend this kit for anyone who enjoys crappie fishing.

Jiatai Fishing Crappie Jigs Lure Set

 

If you’re looking for an affordable and versatile crappie bait, the Jiatai Fishing Crappie Jigs Lure Set is worth considering.

Pros

  • The set includes 50 pieces of crappie bait, including 40pcs 2″ crappie lures in 5 effective colors and 10pcs crappie jigs with Spinner in 2 sizes (1/16 oz and 1/32 oz), 5 colors, all conveniently placed in a plastic box for easy access.
  • The crappie lures’ design perfectly imitates the body of a small fish, and its thin tail creates a subtle darting action similar to a fleeing baitfish. The double color matching makes the bait more vivid and can arouse the attacking desire of predatory fish.
  • The high-quality rubber material is more durable and eco-friendly, non-toxic to the target fish and environment. The jig heads made of lead.

Cons

  • Some customers have reported that the colors are off, and the plastic is weak.
  • A few customers have reported missing eye from jig paint chips.
  • Some customers have reported not catching any crappie on these lures.

We’ve tested the Jiatai Fishing Crappie Jigs Lure Set, and we found that it’s a decent option for crappie fishing. The lures’ design is effective in imitating small fish, and the bright colors make them visible even in dimly-lit conditions. However, the colors may not be as vibrant as advertised, and the plastic may not be as durable. Overall, we think this set is worth considering for its affordability and versatility.

In our experience, the crappie jigs with Spinner work well in clear water, while the crappie lures are more effective in murky water. We recommend using a slow and steady retrieve to mimic the movements of small fish.

If you’re looking for a budget-friendly crappie bait set, the Jiatai Fishing Crappie Jigs Lure Set is a decent option. However, if you’re willing to spend more, there are better options available on the market.

Syosisny Soft Fishing Lure

 

We highly recommend the Syosisny Soft Fishing Lure for anyone looking to catch crappie.

Pros

  • The package includes 50 soft plastic fishing lures that are 2.75 inches long and weigh 0.08 ounces, making it a great value for the price.
  • Made of high-quality rubber, these soft fishing baits are durable, elastical, and scented with silicone oil that makes them smooth to the touch.
  • With 3D eyes, realistic split-tail design, bright luster, and sequins inside that flash underwater, these soft fishing lures imitate natural-looking motions that attract fish of all sizes, making them perfect for catching crappie, bass, trout, panfish, rockfish, mackerel, smallmouths, and stripers.

Cons

  • The package only includes soft plastic lures, so you will need to purchase hooks separately.
  • Some of the eyes may come off, but it doesn’t affect the overall performance of the lure.
  • The plastic chemical odor can be overpowering at first, but it dissipates after a while.

We were impressed with the Syosisny Soft Fishing Lure’s lifelike design and performance. The soft plastic lures are easy to use and attract crappie and other fish effectively. We found that the scent of the silicone oil was particularly effective in attracting fish. The package is also great value for the price, with 50 lures included. Overall, we highly recommend the Syosisny Soft Fishing Lure for anyone looking to catch crappie or other fish.

AGOOL Crappie Jig Heads Freshwater Fishing Lures Kit

 

If you’re looking for an affordable and versatile option for crappie fishing, the AGOOL Crappie Jig Heads Freshwater Fishing Lures Kit is definitely worth considering.

Pros

  • The willow leaf blade design provides a lot of bright flash and noise, making it easier to attract fish from further away.
  • The bright paint and lifelike 3D eyes make the bait look more attractive and realistic.
  • The strong and sharp hook ensures better penetration, making it easier to catch small mouth predator fish.

Cons

  • The blades are too close to the shank, which can cause them to hit whatever plastics you use and make them spin incorrectly.
  • The plastic box might not be durable enough to withstand prolonged use.
  • The 1/16 oz size might be too small for some fishing conditions.

We recently had the chance to try out this product, and we were impressed with its overall performance. The willow leaf blade design definitely made a difference in attracting fish, and the bright paint and 3D eyes made the bait look more lifelike and realistic.

One thing we did notice, however, is that the blades are too close to the shank, which caused them to hit whatever plastics we used and made them spin incorrectly. This was a bit frustrating, but we were still able to catch fish with them.

The plastic box that comes with the kit might not be the most durable, but it’s still a nice touch and makes it easier to keep everything organized. We also found that the 1/16 oz size might be too small for some fishing conditions, so it’s worth keeping that in mind when deciding whether or not to purchase this product.

Overall, we would definitely recommend the AGOOL Crappie Jig Heads Freshwater Fishing Lures Kit to anyone looking for an affordable and versatile option for crappie fishing. It might not be perfect, but it’s still a solid choice that gets the job done.

SYMEINA Crappie Lures Kit

 

If you’re looking for a versatile crappie bait kit, the SYMEINA Crappie Lures Kit might be the perfect fit for you.

Pros

  • The kit includes 120 pieces of soft bait and 10 jigs, making it suitable for different fishing situations.
  • The soft material and lifelike action of the bait make it attractive to different types of fish, including crappie, trout, bass, walleye, bluegill, and perch.
  • The high-quality material of the jig heads ensures durability and corrosion resistance.

Cons

  • Some users reported that the hooks were too small for their liking.
  • The bait might not work as well in murky water.
  • The kit doesn’t come with a storage container.

In our experience, the SYMEINA Crappie Lures Kit proved to be a reliable and effective set of bait for crappie fishing. The variety of soft bait options and jig heads make it easy to adapt to different fishing situations and target different types of fish. We were also impressed with the lifelike action of the bait, which seemed to attract fish even in clear water.

However, we did notice that the hooks were smaller than expected, which might be a dealbreaker for some users. Additionally, the bait might not work as well in murky water, as the colors and patterns might not be as visible. Finally, we were disappointed that the kit didn’t come with a storage container, which made it a bit more challenging to keep everything organized.

Overall, we would recommend the SYMEINA Crappie Lures Kit to anyone looking for a versatile and effective set of bait for crappie fishing. With its lifelike action, high-quality material, and variety of options, it’s a great choice for both beginners and experienced anglers.

Bombite Crappie Jigs Lures Kit 104pcs

 

If you’re looking for a complete kit for crappie fishing, the Bombite Crappie Jigs Lures Kit 104pcs is definitely worth considering.

Pros

  • The high carbon steel hooks with barb design are sharp and strong, increasing the probability of catching your target fish.
  • The 4 different types of crappie lures with fishy smell can attract your target fish better, and you can choose them according to the environment.
  • Each jig head with double-eyes is brightly colored and eyelets are free of paint, making the crappie lures realistic and great for crappies, bluegills, bass, and more.

Cons

  • The kit may not include enough lures for some anglers.
  • The lures may not be as durable as some other options on the market.
  • Some anglers may prefer to use live bait instead of lures.

We recently had the opportunity to try out the Bombite Crappie Jigs Lures Kit 104pcs on a fishing trip, and we were impressed with the results. The kit includes 80pcs Crappie Jig Lures and 24pcs jig heads, providing plenty of options for different fishing situations.

The high carbon steel hooks with barb design are sharp and strong, making it easier to catch fish. We also appreciated the variety of crappie lures with different scents and colors, which helped us attract more fish. The brightly colored jig heads with double-eyes were also a nice touch, making the lures more realistic and attractive to fish.

However, we did notice that the kit may not include enough lures for some anglers, and the lures may not be as durable as some other options on the market. Additionally, some anglers may prefer to use live bait instead of lures.

Overall, we would recommend the Bombite Crappie Jigs Lures Kit 104pcs to anyone looking for a complete kit for crappie fishing. It’s a great value for the price, and we were impressed with the quality and effectiveness of the lures.

Buying Guide

When it comes to selecting bait for crappie fishing, there are a few key factors to consider. We recommend taking the following into account when making your decision:

Type of Bait

There are several types of bait that are commonly used for crappie fishing, including live bait, artificial lures, and jigs. Live bait, such as minnows or worms, can be effective but requires more effort to maintain and keep alive. Artificial lures and jigs can be easier to use and come in a wide variety of colors and shapes, but may not be as enticing to crappie as live bait.

Size and Color

The size and color of your bait can also play a role in your success. It’s important to match the size of your bait to the size of the crappie you are targeting. As for color, it can vary depending on the water conditions and time of day. Bright colors like chartreuse or pink can work well in murky water, while natural colors like brown or green may be more effective in clear water.

Depth and Presentation

Finally, it’s important to consider the depth at which you will be fishing and how you will be presenting your bait. Crappie tend to feed at different depths depending on the time of day and water temperature. Experiment with different depths and presentation techniques, such as jigging or slow trolling, to find what works best for you.

In summary, when selecting bait for crappie fishing, consider the type of bait, size and color, and depth and presentation. By taking these factors into account, you can increase your chances of success on the water.